Talk:Amoeboid - Revision history

Andrio Celos: oops?

2020-07-03T07:42:44Z

oops?

Andrio Celos: /* Do amoeboids include (some) jellies too? */ Probably not.

2020-07-03T07:39:16Z

‎Do amoeboids include (some) jellies too?: Probably not.

Uchronia: /* Do amoeboids include (some) jellies too? */ new section

2020-07-03T06:53:38Z

‎Do amoeboids include (some) jellies too?: new section

New page

== Do amoeboids include (some) jellies too? ==

The page for Ochre Jelly cites this monster as being an amoeboid: https://nethackwiki.com/wiki/Ochre_jelly

Not all jellies are amoeboids, of course, such as the jellyfish. But are some jellies nonetheless included among amoeboids too?

@@ Line 3: / Line 3: @@
 The page for Ochre Jelly cites this monster as being an amoeboid: https://nethackwiki.com/wiki/Ochre_jelly
-Not all jellies are amoeboids, of course, such as the jellyfish. But are some jellies nonetheless included among amoeboids too?
+Not all jellies are amoeboids, of course, such as the jellyfish. But are some jellies nonetheless included among amoeboids too? {{unsigned|Uchronia|06:53, 3 July 2020‎ (UTC)}}
 : {{monsymlink|Jellyfish}} are part of the {{monclass|;}} class, not {{monclass|j}}. However, the article implies that the term refers to the monsters that leave [[glob]]s, which are those in the {{monclass|b}} or {{monclass|P}} class. The only mention in the source code is in the 'blob'/'ooze'/'pudding'/'[[Green slime|slime]]' [[encyclopedia]] entry, all of which are monsters that leave globs. Under this interpretation, jellies are excluded.  - [[User:Andrio Celos|Andrio Celos]] ([[User talk:Andrio Celos|talk]]) 07:38, 3 July 2020 (UTC)

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:39, 3 July 2020
Line 4:		Line 4:

	Not all jellies are amoeboids, of course, such as the jellyfish. But are some jellies nonetheless included among amoeboids too?		Not all jellies are amoeboids, of course, such as the jellyfish. But are some jellies nonetheless included among amoeboids too?
		+
		+	: {{monsymlink\|Jellyfish}} are part of the {{monclass\|;}} class, not {{monclass\|j}}. However, the article implies that the term refers to the monsters that leave [[glob]]s, which are those in the {{monclass\|b}} or {{monclass\|P}} class. The only mention in the source code is in the 'blob'/'ooze'/'pudding'/'[[Green slime\|slime]]' [[encyclopedia]] entry, all of which are monsters that leave globs. Under this interpretation, jellies are excluded. - [[User:Andrio Celos\|Andrio Celos]] ([[User talk:Andrio Celos\|talk]]) 07:38, 3 July 2020 (UTC)