User:Phol ende wodan/DungeonOverhaul/Jonadab - Revision history

Phol ende wodan: /* The Elemental Planes */ add small note

2017-10-09T01:22:02Z

‎The Elemental Planes: add small note

Phol ende wodan: add tocright

2017-10-02T04:24:32Z

add tocright

Phol ende wodan: Fix section levels

2017-10-02T04:21:13Z

Fix section levels

Phol ende wodan: Upload comments to jonadab's proposal

2017-09-29T05:07:02Z

Upload comments to jonadab's proposal

Show changes

@@ Line 1,154: / Line 1,154: @@
   creatures forever, so in some ways it is the most satisfactory ending, although
   it does not provide your own character with immortality.
   The traditional win, by offering the amulet to a diety in exchange for
   immortality, is unchanged from version 3.4.3.
   To keep the amulet for yourself, it is necessary to assert your dominance over
   the Astral Plane by killing everything.  The other Riders do not have to be dead
@@ Line 1,181: / Line 1,179: @@
 "simply", pffft
 I like these additional win conditions. Particularly since they don't make the standard ascension any harder. The other two remind me a bit of the dNetHack anachrononaut, who can choose to save the future by destroying one of the other high altars.
 == [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Object Probabilities|Object Probabilities]] ==

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:24, 2 October 2017
Line 1:		Line 1:
		+	{{tocright}}
		+
	This is a set of comments I drafted in response to [[User:Jonadab\|Jonadab]]'s [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1\|dungeon overhaul proposal]] when he made it public in the summer of 2017. The comments were made with only cursory knowledge of NetHack Fourk, and what had been implemented since the proposal was written.		This is a set of comments I drafted in response to [[User:Jonadab\|Jonadab]]'s [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1\|dungeon overhaul proposal]] when he made it public in the summer of 2017. The comments were made with only cursory knowledge of NetHack Fourk, and what had been implemented since the proposal was written.

@@ Line 277: / Line 277: @@
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Sokoban|Sokoban]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Sokoban|Sokoban]] ===
   There are several reasons why I feel more variants of the Sokoban levels would
@@ Line 367: / Line 367: @@
 For full random generation of Sokoban, this doesn't work.
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Nabokos|Nabokos]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Nabokos|Nabokos]] ===
   The five levels of Nabokos are intended to be more difficult than Sokoban or
@@ Line 441: / Line 441: @@
 I've never seen a good reason for why there can be only one special room per level. Why not d3-1 or d4-1?
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Tribute Level|Tribute Level]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Tribute Level|Tribute Level]] ===
 See above comments, I think adding tributes to other games is a lot of headache for virtually no benefit.
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Medusa's Island|Medusa's Island]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Medusa's Island|Medusa's Island]] ===
   Instead of 1-4 levels above the Castle, Medusa's Island now occurs 3-5 levels
@@ Line 471: / Line 471: @@
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Amazing Maze Zone|Amazing Maze Zone]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Amazing Maze Zone|Amazing Maze Zone]] ===
   The levels below Medusa but above the terminus of the Dungeons of Doom will be
@@ Line 485: / Line 485: @@
 Theseus could be moved to the Mazes of Mystery.
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Terminus|Terminus]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Terminus|Terminus]] ===
   The terminus, or final level of the Dungeons of Doom, occurs at the same depth
@@ Line 591: / Line 591: @@
 Satyrs have a charm attack? Doesn't sit quite right with me.
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Vlad's Tower|Vlad's Tower]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Vlad's Tower|Vlad's Tower]] ===
   In addition to increasing Vlad's basic stats (hitpoints, AC, etc.), I recommend
@@ Line 674: / Line 674: @@
 I think Fourk didn't actually follow this strategy, and it provides scrolls of wishing at various points in Gehennom instead of lamps?
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#The Fire Pits|The Fire Pits]] ==
+== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Middle Gehennom|Middle Gehennom]] ==
   Random item generation in the Fire Pits can, if desired, be given different
@@ Line 719: / Line 721: @@
 Cages make me think of the centaur turrets in one of UnNetHack's Ludios maps.
-== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Swamp of Death|Swamp of Death]] ==
+=== [[User:Jonadab/Dungeon Overhaul Proposal Draft 1#Swamp of Death|Swamp of Death]] ===
   The Swamp of Death is intended to be the more difficult but also more rewarding