Difference between revisions of "Silver spear"

From NetHackWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Added average damage calculation, small line)
Line 12: Line 12:
 
A '''silver spear''' is a kind of [[weapon]]. It can be used in [[melee]], or [[throw]]n. It deals the same base damage as a regular [[spear]], but can also cause [[silver damage]].
 
A '''silver spear''' is a kind of [[weapon]]. It can be used in [[melee]], or [[throw]]n. It deals the same base damage as a regular [[spear]], but can also cause [[silver damage]].
  
It does only one point less damage on average against small or medium monsters than a [[silver saber]], and the same against large monsters (which include most major [[demon]]s), making it an attractive option for roles restricted in saber, such as [[Cavemen]], [[Priest]]s, and especially [[Monk]]s.  Valkeries might also consider this weapon for two weaponing as they can be skilled in spear versus basic skilled in saber.  
+
It does only one point less damage on average against small or medium monsters than a [[silver saber]], and the same against large monsters (which include most major [[demon]]s), making it an attractive option for roles restricted in saber, such as [[Cavemen]], [[Priest]]s, and especially [[Monk]]s.  Valkyries might also consider this weapon for two weaponing as they can be skilled in spear versus basic skilled in saber, overcoming the damage difference.
  
 +
==Average damage calculation==
 +
We assume the player has [[expert skill]] in [[spear]], which gives a +2 damage bonus. A blessed weapon deals 1d4 extra damage against [[demon]]s and [[undead]], and being of silver, an added 1d20 to silver-hating monsters. The worst case scenario is against a non-undead, non-demon, non-silver-hating monster. The best case scenario is against a undead/demon silver-hating monster.
 +
{|class="wikitable"
 +
! Weapon
 +
! Against regular small monsters
 +
! Against regular large monsters
 +
! Worst case scenario
 +
! Best case scenario
 +
|-
 +
|Blessed silver spear+0 || <math>\frac{1+6}{2}+2=\bold{5.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+8}{2}+2=\bold{6.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+6}{2}+2=\bold{5.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+8}{2}+\frac{1+20}{2}+\frac{1+4}{2}+2=\bold{19.5}</math>
 +
|-
 +
|Blessed silver spear +7 || <math>\frac{1+6}{2}+2+7=\bold{12.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+8}{2}+2+7=\bold{13.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+6}{2}+2+7=\bold{12.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+8}{2}+\frac{1+20}{2}+\frac{1+4}{2}+2+7=\bold{26.5}</math>
 +
|-
 +
|Blessed silver spear +9 || <math>\frac{1+6}{2}+2+9=\bold{14.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+8}{2}+2+9=\bold{15.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+6}{2}+2+9=\bold{14.5}</math> || <math>\frac{1+8}{2}+\frac{1+20}{2}+\frac{1+4}{2}+2+9=\bold{28.5}</math>
 +
|}
 +
Despite the inclusion in the above table, attempting to [[Scroll of enchant weapon#Enchanting Beyond +7|enchant a silver spear to +9]] is generally a very bad idea, as they're usually rare.
  
  
 
{{stub}}
 
{{stub}}
 
[[Category:Weapons]]
 
[[Category:Weapons]]

Revision as of 09:03, 29 June 2010

) Silver spear.png
Name silver spear
Appearance silver spear
Damage vs. small 1d6+(1d20)
Damage vs. large 1d8+(1d20)
To-hit bonus +0
Weapon skill spear
Size one-handed
Base price 40 zm
(+10/positive
enchant)
Weight 36
Material silver

A silver spear is a kind of weapon. It can be used in melee, or thrown. It deals the same base damage as a regular spear, but can also cause silver damage.

It does only one point less damage on average against small or medium monsters than a silver saber, and the same against large monsters (which include most major demons), making it an attractive option for roles restricted in saber, such as Cavemen, Priests, and especially Monks.  Valkyries might also consider this weapon for two weaponing as they can be skilled in spear versus basic skilled in saber, overcoming the damage difference.

Average damage calculation

We assume the player has expert skill in spear, which gives a +2 damage bonus. A blessed weapon deals 1d4 extra damage against demons and undead, and being of silver, an added 1d20 to silver-hating monsters. The worst case scenario is against a non-undead, non-demon, non-silver-hating monster. The best case scenario is against a undead/demon silver-hating monster.

Weapon Against regular small monsters Against regular large monsters Worst case scenario Best case scenario
Blessed silver spear+0 \frac{1+6}{2}+2=\bold{5.5} \frac{1+8}{2}+2=\bold{6.5} \frac{1+6}{2}+2=\bold{5.5} \frac{1+8}{2}+\frac{1+20}{2}+\frac{1+4}{2}+2=\bold{19.5}
Blessed silver spear +7 \frac{1+6}{2}+2+7=\bold{12.5} \frac{1+8}{2}+2+7=\bold{13.5} \frac{1+6}{2}+2+7=\bold{12.5} \frac{1+8}{2}+\frac{1+20}{2}+\frac{1+4}{2}+2+7=\bold{26.5}
Blessed silver spear +9 \frac{1+6}{2}+2+9=\bold{14.5} \frac{1+8}{2}+2+9=\bold{15.5} \frac{1+6}{2}+2+9=\bold{14.5} \frac{1+8}{2}+\frac{1+20}{2}+\frac{1+4}{2}+2+9=\bold{28.5}

Despite the inclusion in the above table, attempting to enchant a silver spear to +9 is generally a very bad idea, as they're usually rare.


This page is a stub. Should you wish to do so, you can contribute by expanding this page.